Most of the flood insurance money paid in Fleming Island in the last 10 years came from one storm, Hurricane Irma in 2017.
Fleming Island is not a city. Clay County sets the flood rules, permits, flood maps and CRS discount in Fleming Island. The Census calls it a census designated place: a named area with fixed borders but no mayor or council of its own. That means the Clay County floodplain manager, not a town office, handles flood questions for a Fleming Island home. The Clay County flood insurance guide covers the rest of the county.
Fleming Island flood insurance in 5 numbers
| Number | Fleming Island | Source |
|---|---|---|
| NFIP policies in force | 1,272 | FEMA policy records, July 2026 |
| Policies rated in an A or V zone | 23% | FEMA policy records, July 2026 |
| Average NFIP premium | $871 per policy | FEMA policy records, July 2026 |
| Claims paid, last 10 years | $15,874,031 on 242 claims | FEMA claim records, July 2026 |
| CRS discount | 20%, Class 6, since October 1, 2023 | FEMA CRS list, October 2026 |
FEMA policy records list a county and a Census block group, not a Census place. Every block group behind these Fleming Island figures lies wholly inside Fleming Island, so the numbers are shown as FEMA's records add up, with no rounding.
Fleming Island flood zones: the 2 maps to check
A Fleming Island address sits on two separate maps. One is about insurance, the other is about leaving before a storm.
| FEMA flood zone | Clay County evacuation zone |
|---|---|
| Tells you if a lender can require flood insurance | Tells you if Clay County may order you to leave |
| Look up your FEMA zone | Clay County Evacuation Zone Helper |
The FEMA flood map for Clay County shows zones A, AE and AH, along with lower-risk X areas. That list is for all of Clay County. Nobody has checked it for Fleming Island alone, so any one Fleming Island street could fall in one of those zones or in none.
A zone that begins with A or V is one of FEMA's high-risk areas. If your Fleming Island home is in one and the mortgage is federally backed, the lender must require flood insurance. Zone X has no federal rule, so a lender may or may not ask. In Fleming Island, 77% of NFIP policies (July 2026) insure homes outside the A and V zones. Those owners chose flood coverage, or their lender asked for it anyway. Zone X, AE and VE, explained shows what each zone letter means.
The FEMA flood maps for unincorporated Clay County took effect on March 17, 2014. Clay County says new maps are expected to take effect in spring 2027. To see the zone for one Fleming Island address, use the county's Flood Zone Interactive Map, which also has a button that shows the proposed zones, or the FEMA Flood Map Service Center. You can also use our Clay County flood zone map to find the zone for one address.
The evacuation map is a different thing. Clay County labels its evacuation zones A through E, including the North Prong and South Prong of Black Creek, and it treats every mobile home and manufactured home in the county as Zone A. Type your house number and part of your street name into the Evacuation Zone Helper to find the evacuation zone for a Fleming Island home.
What does flood insurance cost in Fleming Island?
The average Fleming Island NFIP policy costs $871 a year, a little above the Clay County average of $853 (July 2026). An average is only a starting point. Your own quote could land far from it, for three reasons.
1. Same flood zone, very different prices. The zone settles whether a lender can require coverage. It does not set your price. The price looks at the home itself: how high the lowest floor sits, what a rebuild would cost and how often water reaches that spot. So two Fleming Island homes in the same zone can get quotes that are far apart. An elevation certificate may bring an NFIP price down, and a lender must take a private policy that meets the federal rules. What decides your flood insurance price explains why two Fleming Island homes in one zone can pay different amounts.
2. Clay County's 20% discount. Unincorporated Clay County, which takes in Fleming Island, is one NFIP community with one Community Rating System (CRS) class. FEMA rates it Class 6, worth 20% off eligible NFIP premiums. Clay County joined the CRS on October 1, 1996, and has been Class 6 since October 1, 2023. The Town of Orange Park is a separate NFIP community with its own flood rules.
Your declarations page should show the 20% CRS credit. Check my address to confirm your Fleming Island home is in unincorporated Clay County.
3. A claim record that is mostly recent. Fleming Island has 335 NFIP claims on record all time, and 242 of them came in the last 10 years. One storm, Irma, paid most of that money. A zone outside A or V is lower risk, not no risk, and that record is why the price weighs how often your own spot floods.
ZIPs that cover part of the Fleming Island area, Clay County
One ZIP code covers the Fleming Island area in Clay County. A ZIP code does not follow city limits. When a ZIP is shared, its numbers are for the whole ZIP, not only the Fleming Island part.
| ZIP | Shared with | NFIP policies | Average premium paid (a year) | Share in high-risk zones | NFIP claims, last 10 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 32003 | No other city | 1,271 | $870 | 23% | 241 |
An average is not a price. Under Risk Rating 2.0, two homes in the same Fleming Island ZIP and the same flood zone can pay very different amounts.
Look up any Florida ZIP in the flood insurance by ZIP code table.
Clay County contacts for a Fleming Island home
| Who | Phone | What they handle |
|---|---|---|
| Clay County Division of Emergency Management | (877) 252-9362 | Evacuation orders, storm alerts, shelter openings |
| Clay County Planning and Zoning (floodplain manager) | (904) 541-3825 | Flood zones, flood maps, permits and rebuild rules for Fleming Island |
Fleming Island has no town hall, so Clay County answers its flood questions. Call the floodplain manager about a zone, a permit or a rebuild. For an emergency, dial 9-1-1.
Shelters. Clay County keeps no standing list of shelter sites. When a storm comes, the county names the shelters that are open through local media and ClayCountyGov.com, and pet friendly shelters may open too. In the county's own words: "Not all shelters open for every storm." The county calls a public shelter a last resort, so plan another safe place to stay first, and wait for the county to say a shelter is open.
If you live in Fleming Island and will need help to leave, sign up on the Clay County Special Medical Needs Registry before storm season starts. The county says signing up does not promise a ride or a shelter spot. To get Clay County warnings, sign up for Alert Clay.
More help: the Clay County Division of Emergency Management.
If your Fleming Island home floods: 5 steps
- Stay out of flood water, on foot and in a car.
- Before you clean anything, take photos and video of every room.
- Call your insurance company and start the claim the same day.
- Write down everything the water ruined. Save every cleanup and repair receipt.
- Ask Clay County what permits you need before you rebuild. The floodplain manager is at (904) 541-3825.
The 50% rule. When repairs would cost 50% or more of a building's market value, federal rules call it "substantially damaged." The home then has to meet today's flood rules, and that can mean raising it. Clay County applies this rule to Fleming Island homes, so ask the county how it will value your building before work begins. Increased Cost of Compliance (ICC) coverage on an NFIP policy can help pay for it.
Clay County flood events in FEMA records
FEMA totals storm claims by county, not by Census place. Every row below is a Clay County total. The Fleming Island 10-year figure, $15,874,031, is in the table near the top of this page.
| Flood event | Year | NFIP claims in Clay County | Paid in Clay County |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hurricane Irma | 2017 | 765 | $60,670,001 |
| Hurricane Nicole | 2022 | 21 | $1,204,262 |
| Hurricane Ian | 2022 | 7 | $182,129 |
| Hurricane Milton | 2024 | 2 | $109,395 |
| December Nor'easter | 2023 | 3 | $12,248 |
Irma paid more in Clay County than the next four events in this table combined, many times over. The quiet years since then are not a promise about the next storm.
Buying or closing in Fleming Island? Read this first
Only 23% of Fleming Island NFIP policies (July 2026) are rated in a high-risk zone, so look up the zone for the exact address before you count on a lender rule either way. In an A or V zone with a federally backed loan, the lender will want proof of flood insurance before closing. In Zone X, the lender may not ask, and the choice is yours. Ask the seller for an elevation certificate and whether the seller's flood policy can be assigned to you. Read Florida's seller flood disclosure law so you know what to ask about the home's flood past.
A new NFIP policy usually waits 30 days before it starts. The main exception: a policy bought as part of making, refinancing, increasing, extending or renewing a loan on the home can start at closing with no wait, if the application and payment are in by closing. If a new flood map moves a home into a high-risk zone, a policy bought within 13 months of the map date waits only one day. With Clay County expecting new maps in spring 2027, that rule may matter to Fleming Island buyers soon. A lender that asks for coverage partway through a loan does not trigger either exception. Private flood policies set their own waiting periods, and many are shorter.
Your lender must accept a private flood policy that meets the federal definition of private flood insurance. Look for that wording on the policy, or ask the lender. Private flood may cost less than the NFIP for some Fleming Island homes and more for others. Compare it with an NFIP quote that already has Clay County's 20% discount in it. What a lender can require.
Buying in Fleming Island? Start with the buyer guide
Fleming Island flood insurance: 6 questions
How much is flood insurance in Fleming Island? The NFIP average is $871 per policy, per FEMA records from July 2026, a little above the Clay County average of $853. Your own price depends on the home: its height, its rebuild cost and how often the spot floods.
Is Fleming Island a city? No. Fleming Island is a census designated place in unincorporated Clay County. Clay County sets its flood rules, permits, flood maps and CRS discount.
Does Fleming Island get a flood insurance discount? Yes, through Clay County. FEMA has rated unincorporated Clay County Class 6 in the Community Rating System since October 1, 2023, worth 20% off eligible NFIP premiums.
How much has flood insurance paid in Fleming Island? $15,874,031 on 242 NFIP claims in the last 10 years, per FEMA records from July 2026. Most of that money came from one storm, Hurricane Irma in 2017.
Do I need flood insurance in Fleming Island if I am in Zone X? A lender does not have to require it in Zone X. Still, 77% of Fleming Island NFIP policies (July 2026) insure homes outside the high-risk zones. Rain and storms can flood a home in any zone. More on Zone X.
What evacuation zone am I in? Type your Fleming Island address into Clay County's Evacuation Zone Helper. Your evacuation zone is not your FEMA flood zone, and it does not decide whether you need flood insurance.
Explore Clay County and Florida flood guides
- Clay County flood insurance: county numbers, flood events and contacts
- Clay County flood zone map: find your zone by address
- Duval County flood insurance: the county to the north
- St. Johns County flood insurance: across the St. Johns River to the east
- Putnam County flood insurance: the county to the south
- Florida flood insurance: the statewide picture
- The 30-day wait and its exceptions
- Flood insurance questions, answered
Sources: OpenFEMA NFIP policies and claims (FEMA, data as of July 4, 2026, Fleming Island by Census block group); OpenFEMA NFIP Community Status Book, unincorporated Clay County row (CID 120064, read November 14, 2026); FEMA CRS Eligible Communities, October 1, 2026; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, Clay County (read November 10, 2026); OpenFEMA NFIP claims by storm, Clay County; OpenFEMA NFIP claims for Fleming Island block groups (read November 14, 2026), storm names as FEMA records them; Clay County Emergency Management, evacuation zone and shelter pages (read November 13, 2026); Clay County Flood Zone Changes page and flood zone map (read November 13, 2026); Clay County Emergency Management and Flood/FEMA Info pages, phones (read November 8, 2026); Clay County Alert Clay and Special Medical Needs pages (read November 17, 2026); U.S. Census 2020 and 2024 Gazetteer.
Lender says you need flood insurance? Read what the law requires and what you still choose.
Own a business, condo or apartment building in Fleming Island? Read the Florida commercial flood insurance guide.
Page data last verified 2026-11-14. Every figure links to the federal or county record it came from.