Most of the flood insurance money paid in Carrollwood in the last 10 years came from one storm, Hurricane Milton in 2024.
Carrollwood is not a city. Hillsborough County sets the flood rules, permits, flood maps and CRS discount in Carrollwood. The Census calls it a census designated place: a well-known community with set lines on the map but no mayor or city hall. Any Carrollwood flood zone, permit or rebuild question goes to Hillsborough County staff. The Hillsborough County flood insurance guide has the numbers for the whole county.
Carrollwood flood insurance: 5 key numbers
| What we counted | Carrollwood | Source |
|---|---|---|
| NFIP policies in force | about 990 | FEMA policy records, July 2026 |
| Policies rated in an A or V zone | about 17% | FEMA policy records, July 2026 |
| Average NFIP premium | about $429 per policy | FEMA policy records, July 2026 |
| Claims paid, last 10 years | about $3.98 million on about 54 claims | FEMA claim records, July 2026 |
| CRS discount | 30%, Class 4, since October 1, 2026 | FEMA CRS list, October 2026 |
FEMA's policy files do not say which Census place a home is in. So we built the Carrollwood numbers from Census block groups, the small neighborhoods the Census maps. Four block groups at the edge cross the Carrollwood line, and we split each one by where its homes sit. That is why the figures are rounded down and marked "about."
Carrollwood flood zones: 2 maps, 2 questions
Each Carrollwood address sits on two maps. They do different jobs.
| FEMA flood zone | Hillsborough evacuation zone |
|---|---|
| Tells you whether a lender can require flood insurance | Tells you whether and when to leave for a storm (zones A to E) |
| Look up your FEMA zone | Hillsborough evacuation zone lookup |
The Hillsborough County flood study names zones A, AE, AH, AO and VE, plus lower-risk X areas. That list is for the whole county, bay shore and all. Nobody has made a list for Carrollwood alone, so a Carrollwood street may fall in some of these zones and not others.
FEMA calls the zones that start with A or V high-risk areas. If a Carrollwood home in one of them has a federally backed mortgage, the lender must require flood insurance. Zone X carries no federal rule, and each lender decides for itself. More than 4 in 5 Carrollwood NFIP policies (July 2026) insure homes outside the A and V zones, so many owners there carry a policy by choice. Zone X, AE and VE, explained shows what each zone letter means in Hillsborough County.
Unincorporated Hillsborough County, Carrollwood included, has used its current flood maps since October 7, 2021. To check the zone for one Carrollwood address, try our Hillsborough County flood zone map, the county's Find My Flood Zone page or the FEMA Flood Map Service Center. What decides your flood insurance price explains why two Carrollwood homes can pay different amounts.
How much is flood insurance in Carrollwood?
A Carrollwood NFIP policy averages about $429 a year. The Hillsborough County average is $1,352 (July 2026), so Carrollwood comes in at less than a third of the county figure. Carrollwood's about 990 policies sit on about 970 policy records, because FEMA counts each unit under a condo building policy as a policy of its own. Your own price can land far from it. Three things set it.
1. Same flood zone, very different prices. The zone tells a lender whether a policy is required. The price comes from the house: the height of its lowest floor, what it would cost to rebuild and how often water has reached that lot. Two Carrollwood homes in one zone, even on one street, can get quotes far apart. An elevation certificate can lower an NFIP price for some homes, and a lender has to accept a private policy that meets the federal rules.
2. Hillsborough County's 30% discount. Carrollwood is part of unincorporated Hillsborough County, a single NFIP community with one Community Rating System (CRS) class. On FEMA's October 2026 list it is Class 4, worth 30% off eligible NFIP premiums since October 1, 2026. The county has been in the CRS since October 1, 1992. Tampa, Plant City and Temple Terrace are rated on their own.
Is the 30% credit on your Carrollwood bill? Look for a CRS credit on your declarations page. Check my address to see which NFIP community your home is in.
3. Carrollwood's claim record. FEMA lists about 149 NFIP claims in Carrollwood all time, and about 54 of them came in the last 10 years. So Carrollwood homes flooded long before Milton. A home outside the high-risk zones is not a home that never floods.
ZIPs that cover part of the Carrollwood area, Hillsborough County
2 ZIP codes cover part of the Carrollwood area in Hillsborough County. A ZIP code does not follow city limits. When a ZIP is shared, its numbers are for the whole ZIP, not only the Carrollwood part.
| ZIP | Shared with | NFIP policies | Average premium paid (a year) | Share in high-risk zones | NFIP claims, last 10 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 33624 | Northdale area | 1,109 | $504 | 30% | 130 |
| 33618 | Lake Magdalene area | 954 | $394 | 24% | 57 |
An average is not a price. Under Risk Rating 2.0, two homes in the same Carrollwood ZIP and the same flood zone can pay very different amounts.
Look up any Florida ZIP in the flood insurance by ZIP code table.
Hillsborough County contacts for Carrollwood homes
| Who | Phone | What they handle |
|---|---|---|
| Hillsborough County Office of Emergency Management | (813) 272-6600 | Evacuation orders, shelter openings, storm updates |
| Hillsborough County Public Works Floodplain Administration | (813) 635-5400 | Flood maps, flood zones, permits and flood rules for Carrollwood |
Carrollwood has no city hall, so its flood questions go to the county. Call Hillsborough County Floodplain Administration at (813) 635-5400 or write to floodplainadmin@hcfl.gov about a zone, a permit or rebuilding after a flood.
Shelters. Hillsborough County chooses which shelters to open for each storm, so the list changes. For Hurricane Milton in 2024, the county opened Middleton High School, 4801 N. 22nd St., Tampa (pet-friendly), Burnett Middle School, 1010 N. Kingsway Rd., Seffner (pet-friendly) and Erwin Technical College, 2010 E. Hillsborough Ave., Tampa (special needs; sign up with the county first). None of them is in Carrollwood. Before you leave Carrollwood for any shelter, make sure it is open on the county evacuation zone lookup or by calling (813) 272-6600.
More help: the Hillsborough County Office of Emergency Management.
If your Carrollwood home floods: 5 steps
- Stay out of flood water, on foot or in a car.
- Take photos and video of the damage in each room before cleanup starts.
- Report the claim to your insurance company right away.
- Write down everything the water ruined. Save every cleanup and repair receipt.
- Ask Hillsborough County Floodplain Administration, (813) 635-5400, which permits you need before you rebuild.
The 50% rule. If repairs would cost 50% or more of a building's market value, federal rules say the home is "substantially damaged." It must then meet today's flood rules, which can mean raising it. Hillsborough County counts the building's value alone, not the land, and adds up repair costs across 12 months. Free labor and donated materials count at market prices. Increased Cost of Compliance (ICC) coverage on an NFIP policy can help pay for the work.
5 storms in Hillsborough County flood claims
FEMA does not report storm totals for each community. These figures cover all of Hillsborough County. Carrollwood's own 10-year figure, about $3.98 million, is in the table near the top of this page.
| Storm | Year | NFIP claims in Hillsborough County | Paid in Hillsborough County |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hurricane Helene | 2024 | 7,418 | $878,752,171 |
| Hurricane Milton | 2024 | 2,625 | $190,457,451 |
| Hurricane Idalia | 2023 | 289 | $20,746,601 |
| Hurricane Eta | 2020 | 167 | $6,997,747 |
| Hurricane Irma | 2017 | 300 | $5,555,275 |
Across Hillsborough County, Helene paid the most of these five. In Carrollwood, Milton is the storm behind most of the last 10 years' flood claim money. One storm can land harder on one part of a county than on the rest.
Buying a home in Carrollwood?
Only about 17% of Carrollwood's NFIP policies (July 2026) are in a high-risk zone, so look up the zone of the exact house before you count on any lender rule. In an A or V zone with a federally backed loan, expect the lender to ask for proof of flood insurance before closing. In Zone X the lender may not ask, and the choice is yours. Ask the seller for an elevation certificate, whether their flood policy can be passed to you, and how the house came through Hurricane Milton. Florida's seller flood disclosure law covers what a seller has to tell you.
Most new NFIP policies wait 30 days before they start. The main exception: when you buy the policy as part of making, refinancing, increasing, extending or renewing a loan on the home, it can start at closing, as long as the application and payment are in by then. A home that a new flood map moves into a high-risk zone has another exception: a policy bought within 13 months of the map change waits just one day. Hillsborough County's maps from October 7, 2021 are long past that window. If a lender asks for flood coverage in the middle of a loan, the 30-day wait still applies. Private flood policies set their own waits, and many are shorter.
A lender must accept a private flood policy that meets the federal definition of private flood insurance. Look for that wording on the policy, or ask the lender. A private quote beats the NFIP for some Carrollwood homes and not for others. Set it next to an NFIP price that already has Hillsborough County's 30% discount in it. What a lender can require.
Buying in Carrollwood? Start with the buyer guide
Carrollwood flood insurance: 6 questions
What does flood insurance cost in Carrollwood? About $429 per NFIP policy on average, per FEMA records from July 2026, well under the Hillsborough County average of $1,352. Your own price depends on your home: its floor height, rebuild cost and flood history.
Is Carrollwood, FL a city? No. Carrollwood is a census designated place in unincorporated Hillsborough County. The county sets Carrollwood's flood maps, flood rules, permits and CRS discount.
Do I need flood insurance in Carrollwood if my home is in Zone X? A lender does not have to require it in Zone X. Even so, more than 4 in 5 Carrollwood NFIP policies (July 2026) cover homes outside the high-risk zones, and heavy rain can flood a home in any zone. More on Zone X.
Do Carrollwood homes get a flood insurance discount? Yes, through Hillsborough County. FEMA rates unincorporated Hillsborough County Class 4 in the Community Rating System, 30% off eligible NFIP premiums, since October 1, 2026.
How much has flood insurance paid in Carrollwood? About $3.98 million on about 54 NFIP claims in the last 10 years, per FEMA records from July 2026. Most of that money came from Hurricane Milton in 2024.
How do I find my Carrollwood evacuation zone? Hillsborough County uses zones A to E. Type your Carrollwood address into the county's evacuation zone lookup. Your evacuation zone is not your FEMA flood zone, and it does not decide whether you need flood insurance.
More flood guides for Hillsborough County and Florida
- Hillsborough County flood insurance: county numbers, storms and phone numbers
- Hillsborough County flood zone map: look up a zone by address
- City of Tampa flood insurance: its own NFIP community with its own CRS class
- Town 'n' Country flood insurance: another unincorporated Hillsborough community
- Pinellas County flood insurance: across Old Tampa Bay to the west
- Florida flood insurance: the statewide picture
- The 30-day wait and its exceptions
- Flood insurance questions, answered
Sources: OpenFEMA NFIP policies and claims (FEMA, data as of July 4, 2026, split to Carrollwood by Census block group and 2020 housing units); OpenFEMA NFIP Community Status Book, unincorporated Hillsborough County row (CID 120112, read November 14, 2026); FEMA CRS Eligible Communities, October 1, 2026; FEMA Flood Insurance Study for Hillsborough County, revised October 7, 2021, zone list; OpenFEMA NFIP claims by storm, Hillsborough County; OpenFEMA NFIP claims for the Carrollwood block groups (read November 14, 2026), storm names as FEMA records them; Hillsborough County Emergency Management, evacuation lookup and Flood Maps pages (read July 6, 2026); Hillsborough County Substantial Damage/Improvement Guidelines (read July 6, 2026); Hillsborough County Hurricane Milton shelter list (October 2024); U.S. Census 2020 and 2024 Gazetteer.
Lender says you need flood insurance? Read what the law requires and what you still choose.
Own a business, condo or apartment building in Carrollwood? Read the Florida commercial flood insurance guide.
Page data last verified 2026-11-14. Every figure links to the federal or county record it came from.